July 1, 2026
Why AI-Written Resumes Are Getting Rejected in 2025
Why AI-Written Resumes Are Getting Rejected in 2025
The case against paying for a professional resume writer usually goes: "I can do it myself, I know my own career, and how hard can it be?" The case for it usually goes: "I've applied to forty jobs and heard nothing." Both of those things can be true at the same time.
This isn't a sales pitch — it's an honest breakdown of what each option actually costs, where the real value difference sits, and how to figure out which one makes sense for where you are right now.
Already have a resume — DIY or otherwise? Start with a free ATS scan to see exactly where it stands.
Scan my resume free →The hidden cost of doing it yourself
What a DIY resume actually costs
$320
average weekly earnings lost per week of extended job search for a mid-level professional. Most people focus on what a resume writer charges. Very few calculate what every extra week of silence — missed calls, no interviews — actually costs them.
The direct cost of writing your own resume is low. A Google Doc template is free. A Canva resume costs nothing. The time cost is real but manageable — most people spend 4–10 hours on a first draft. The invisible cost is what makes the comparison interesting: the applications that go nowhere, the searches that drag weeks longer than they should, and the salary left on the table when you finally do get an offer.
DIY resume — real cost breakdown
Template / tool cost $0–$30
Time to write (8 hrs @ avg salary) $200–$500
ATS scanner / proofreader $0–$40
Each extra week of job search (missed earnings + delayed start) $320–$1,200+
Salary negotiation left on table (no positioning help) $2,000–$8,000+
That last line is the one most people skip. A professional writer doesn't just help you get interviews faster — they position your experience to support a stronger salary conversation. The difference between "seeking a role in the $80–90k range" and "targeting senior-level roles at $95–105k" often starts with how a resume frames the candidate.
What pro writers charge
What professional resume writers actually cost in 2025
The range is wide — because quality and what's included varies enormously. Here's how the market breaks down across experience levels:
Professional resume writer — typical pricing by level
Entry-level / graduate (0–3 years) $150–$350
Mid-level professional (3–10 years) $300–$600
Senior / manager (10–20 years) $500–$900
Executive / C-suite (director+) $900–$2,500+
ResumeThrive (all levels) from $149
Free first step
See where your resume stands before you decide
Run a free ATS scan and get your keyword match score in 60 seconds — then decide whether to fix it yourself or let us do it.
Get my free ATS score →Side by side
DIY vs professional writer — the real comparison
| Factor | DIY resume | Professional writer |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | $0–$50 | $149–$2,500+ |
| Time investment | 8–20+ hours of your time | 1–3 hours (intake call + review) |
| ATS keyword coverage | Depends on self-research; often incomplete | Systematically matched to target role |
| Bullet point quality | Usually task-focused without coaching | Outcome-driven, quantified, role-targeted |
| Blind spots | Hard to see your own gaps in positioning | External perspective catches what you miss |
| Salary positioning | Rarely addressed explicitly | Framed to support target compensation |
| Interview rate | Variable; often low without iteration | Typically higher from day one |
| Revision rounds | Unlimited, but all on your time | Included rounds; faster turnaround |
When each makes sense
Who should write their own resume — and who shouldn't
DIY works well when…
- You're early career and cost is the primary constraint
- You're staying in the same industry and role level
- You have time to research, iterate, and test
- You're updating an already-working resume
- You've used a professional before and just need a refresh
A pro is worth it when…
- You've been applying for 3+ weeks with no response
- You're making a career change or returning after a gap
- You're targeting a step up in seniority or salary
- You're applying into a highly competitive role or market
- The salary uplift is 5x+ the cost of the service
The silence cost
The number most people don't calculate
Here's the calculation that usually tips the decision. Say you're a mid-level professional targeting a $90,000 role, you've been job searching for six weeks, and you're getting no interview calls. A $400 professional resume rewrite feels expensive. But if it shortens your search by three weeks, you've already recovered $1,700 in earnings. If it also helps you walk into that role at $95k instead of $90k, you've made back $5,000 in year one alone.
The honest answer isn't "always hire a pro" or "always DIY." It's: calculate what silence is actually costing you, then decide.
-
Six weeks of applications with zero responses is not a job market problem. That is a resume problem. At that point the cost of inaction has already exceeded almost any professional service fee.
-
Cheap services are often worse than DIY. A $49 "resume mill" that runs your details through a template and outputs a generic document isn't a professional rewrite. Check for real writers, real intake calls, and real before/after samples before paying anyone.
-
A professional writer can't invent experience you don't have. The value is in positioning and framing — not fabrication. If a service promises to "make you look more qualified than you are," walk away.
Not sure if your DIY resume is the problem? A free ATS scan gives you a keyword gap report in 60 seconds.
Scan my resume free →If you go DIY
How to get the most from a self-written resume
If the DIY route is the right call for you right now, here's how to do it in a way that closes the gap with a professional result as much as possible.
DIY resume quality checklist
- Start from the job description — pull the exact keywords and mirror their language in your skills and bullets
- Rewrite every bullet to lead with an outcome, not a task — and add a number to at least 60% of them
- Ask someone outside your industry to read it: if they can't tell what you're good at in 10 seconds, rewrite the summary
- Use a single-column, plain-text-compatible format — no tables, icons, or columns
- Run it through a free ATS scanner before each application to check keyword coverage
- Save as a PDF from a clean Word or Google Doc, not from a design tool with embedded graphics
- Sit on it for 24 hours then re-read it — you'll catch what you missed the first time
One last step
Find out what your resume is missing — free
Whether you wrote it yourself or worked with a professional, our free ATS scanner tells you exactly how your resume scores against the role you're targeting — so you know what to fix before you apply.
Get my free ATS score →